Which Is The Best AI Detection Tool? (BIG Surprise!)

Jason West
16 May 202311:16

TLDRIn this video, Jason tests the latest AI detection tools to determine the best one. Using GPT-4, he generates a 500-word article to see how well these tools can detect AI-generated content. Jason reviews several AI detectors, including Winston AI, AI Detector Pro, Originality, GPTZero, CrossPlag, and OpenAI's own detector. He finds that Winston AI and Originality are the most reliable, while others, including GPTZero and OpenAI's detector, fail to accurately identify the AI-generated text. Jason provides insights on the features of these tools and concludes with recommendations.

Takeaways

  • ๐Ÿ•ต๏ธโ€โ™‚๏ธ The video tests the latest AI detection tools to determine which is the best at identifying AI-generated content.
  • ๐Ÿ“ Jason uses GPT-4 to generate a 500-word article with light humor, mimicking human writing style to trick AI detectors.
  • ๐Ÿ“ˆ Google Trends data shows a significant rise in interest in AI detection, particularly in African nations, Pakistan, Singapore, China, and the Philippines.
  • ๐ŸŽ“ Turnitin is highlighted as a popular tool used by educational institutions for plagiarism detection, but not freely available to the public.
  • ๐Ÿ“ The generated article by GPT-4 is upbeat and human-like, incorporating humor and analogies to appear more natural.
  • ๐Ÿ” AI detectors tested include Winston AI, AI Detector Pro, GPT Zero, CrossPlag, and a Chrome plugin called Percent Human.
  • ๐Ÿšซ Some detectors require paid plans for full functionality, limiting the testing scope for certain tools.
  • ๐Ÿค– GPT Zero incorrectly identified the AI-generated text as likely written by a human, suggesting it may not be as effective as believed.
  • ๐Ÿ”‘ Winston and Originality were the only two detectors that successfully identified the AI-generated content, standing out among the tested tools.
  • ๐ŸŒ Originality offers a website scanner feature, useful for scanning entire sites for AI-generated content, a unique advantage.
  • ๐Ÿ”„ Open AI's own detector failed to identify its system-generated content, indicating potential limitations in its detection capabilities.

Q & A

  • What is the main purpose of the video by Jason?

    -The main purpose of the video is to test the latest AI detection tools to determine which one is the best at detecting AI-generated content.

  • When was the video made?

    -The video was made in the middle of May 2023.

  • What did Jason ask Chat GPT to do in the video?

    -Jason asked Chat GPT to write a 500-word article on how AI-generated content can help small business owners accelerate the growth of their company, with a human-like style and occasional light humor.

  • What is Google Trends showing about the interest in AI detection tools?

    -Google Trends shows a significant increase in interest in AI detection tools over the last four months, with high interest in regions like Kenya, Tunisia, Pakistan, Singapore, China, and the Philippines.

  • What is Turnitin and why is it mentioned in the video?

    -Turnitin is a plagiarism detection service widely used by educational institutions like universities, schools, and colleges. It is mentioned as a popular tool for AI detection.

  • Which AI detection tools did Jason test in the video?

    -Jason tested several AI detection tools, including Winston AI, AI Detector Pro, GPT Zero, CrossPlag, a browser plugin called Percent Human, and Open AI's own detector.

  • What were the results of the AI detection tests conducted by Jason?

    -The results varied, but Winston and Originality were the only two tools that successfully detected the AI-generated content, while GPT Zero and others failed to do so.

  • Why did Jason include humor and a human-like writing style in the article written by Chat GPT?

    -Jason included humor and a human-like writing style to make the AI-generated content seem more human and to test if these elements could trick AI detection tools.

  • What is the URL provided in the video for testing AI detectors?

    -The URL provided for testing AI detectors is chatgptdetectors.com.

  • What features does Winston AI offer according to the video?

    -Winston AI offers a dashboard for project management, the ability to check for plagiarism, and the capability to upload and scan various file formats like PDF, Word documents, JPEG, and PNG.

  • What is the website scanner feature offered by Originality?

    -The website scanner feature by Originality allows users to scan an entire website for AI-generated content by simply entering the URL and clicking scan.

Outlines

00:00

๐Ÿงช Testing AI Detection Tools

Jason introduces the video topic: testing various AI detection tools to see which one performs best as of May 2023. He plans to generate content with GPT-4 and use common tricks people claim will help bypass AI detectors. He starts by asking GPT-4 to write a 500-word article about AI-generated content helping small businesses, including light humor. Jason highlights the rising interest in AI detection tools, especially in regions like Kenya, Tunisia, Pakistan, Singapore, China, and the Philippines, based on Google Trends. He notes that 'Turnitin' is a popular tool among educational institutions for detecting AI-generated content.

05:00

๐Ÿ“ˆ Trends in AI Detection

Jason analyzes the article GPT-4 generated about AI assisting small business growth. He begins testing it with various AI detection tools, including Winston AI, AI Detector Pro, and Originality. While Winston AI and Originality accurately identify the content as AI-generated, GPT-0 and CrossPlag misidentify it as human-written. Jason explains how GPT-0's reputation may be overstated, and discusses the limitations of each tool tested. He also mentions that OpenAI's own detector struggles to identify its own generated content as AI-written.

10:03

๐Ÿ” Comparing AI Detection Tools

Jason compares the features of Winston AI and Originality, the two AI detectors that successfully identified the GPT-4 generated content as AI-written. Winston AI offers a user-friendly dashboard, project management, plagiarism checks, and file uploads for various formats. Originality provides a website scanner, which can be beneficial for content creators and publishers, but lacks document upload functionality. Jason concludes by directing viewers to chatgptdetectors.com to test various AI detectors themselves and find the best one. He wraps up the video with a call to like, subscribe, and watch upcoming content.

Mindmap

Keywords

๐Ÿ’กAI Detection Tools

AI detection tools are software applications designed to identify whether a piece of content has been generated by artificial intelligence. In the video, various AI detection tools are tested to see how accurately they can identify content generated by ChatGPT.

๐Ÿ’กChatGPT

ChatGPT is an AI language model developed by OpenAI. In the video, it is used to generate an article, which is then tested with different AI detection tools to see if they can recognize it as AI-generated content.

๐Ÿ’กGPT-4

GPT-4 is the fourth generation of OpenAI's Generative Pre-trained Transformer models. It is used in the video to generate content that is then tested with AI detection tools, highlighting its ability to produce human-like text.

๐Ÿ’กGoogle Trends

Google Trends is a tool that analyzes the popularity of search queries over time. The video uses Google Trends to show the increasing interest in AI detection tools since the release of ChatGPT.

๐Ÿ’กTurnitin

Turnitin is a widely used plagiarism detection service, particularly in educational institutions. It is mentioned in the video as a popular tool for detecting AI-generated content in academic settings.

๐Ÿ’กWinston AI

Winston AI is one of the AI detection tools tested in the video. It successfully identifies the ChatGPT-generated article as AI-generated, demonstrating its effectiveness.

๐Ÿ’กOriginality

Originality is another AI detection tool tested in the video. Like Winston AI, it correctly identifies the ChatGPT-generated content as AI-generated, showing its reliability.

๐Ÿ’กGPTZero

GPTZero is an AI detection tool that the video tests. Surprisingly, it fails to identify the ChatGPT-generated content as AI-generated, suggesting it might not be as effective as some other tools.

๐Ÿ’กCrossplag

Crossplag is an AI detection tool mentioned in the video. It also fails to recognize the ChatGPT-generated content as AI-generated, similar to GPTZero.

๐Ÿ’กOpenAI Detector

The OpenAI Detector is a tool developed by OpenAI to identify AI-generated content. In the video, it surprisingly fails to detect content generated by ChatGPT, despite being designed by the same company.

Highlights

Video aims to test the latest AI detection tools to determine which is the best.

AI detection tools are being tested with content generated by chat GPT and GPT4.

Tricks from comments are used to try and trick AI detection systems.

A 500-word article is requested from chat GPT to be written as a human with light humor.

Google Trends data shows a significant rise in interest for AI detection, especially in African nations, Pakistan, Singapore, China, and the Philippines.

Turnitin is identified as a leading tool for AI detection, primarily used by educational institutions.

The article generated by GPT4 is reviewed for its human-like style and humor.

A list of AI detectors is provided for testing, with a link to chatgptdetectors.com.

Winston AI confidently identifies the article as AI-generated with a high AI score.

AI Detector Pro is unable to analyze the full text due to a need for a paid plan.

GPT Zero incorrectly identifies the article as likely written entirely by a human.

CrossPlag also fails to detect the AI-generated content, marking it as mainly human-written.

A Chrome plugin called Percent Human incorrectly identifies the content as 100% generated.

Open AI's own detector fails to recognize its system's generated content, classifying it as unlikely AI-generated.

Winston and Originality are identified as the top AI detectors, successfully identifying AI content.

Winston offers a dashboard for project management and document scanning in various formats.

Originality provides a website scanner for checking entire sites for AI-generated content.

The video concludes that using humor and human-like writing can trick most AI detection tools.